Friday, May 18, 2007

The Legacy of Hegel's Evolutionary Dialectic Philosophy on The Evolution of Western and Eastern Philosophy and Culture

G.W. Hegel (1770-1831) was either loved or hated for his revolutionary philosophical work in 'The Phenomemnology of Mind(Spirit)', published in 1807. Kierkegaard, Schopenhauer, and Nietzsche all were heavily influenced by Hegel -- even in largely rejecting his most prized work -- and each went on to write his own passionate 'anti-thesis' against Hegel's philosophy. (How many 'anti-theses' can one philosophical theory have? In Hegel's case, the answer seems to be 'many'! Ironically, as each of Kierkegaard, Schopenhauer, and Nietzsche were writing their own respective 'theoretical compensations and retaliations' to Hegel's work, one could/can easily argue that they were just adding more 'fuel to the fire of Hegel's theory' because they were each showing the creativity of the human dialectic at work just as Hegel had argued that it was in every aspect of human thinking and cultural activity. 'Thesis', 'anti-thesis', and 'synthesis' -- These three terms were not actually Hegel's, and from what I understand, he only used them once in his work -- but he made them famous and they have been associated with his work every since. See below.*


.....................................................................................

*Although he never used the terms himself, the triad thesis, antithesis, synthesis is often used to describe the thought of German philosopher Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel. It is often thought to form part of an analysis of historical and philosophical progress called the Hegelian dialectic.

It is usually described in the following way:

The thesis is an intellectual proposition.
The antithesis is simply the negation of the thesis.
The synthesis solves the conflict between the thesis and antithesis by reconciling their common truths, and forming a new proposition.

Hegel used this classification only once, and he attributed the terminology to Immanuel Kant. The terminology was largely developed earlier by Fichte the neo-Kantian. The idea was subsequently extended and adopted by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels.

* Reference: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
.....................................................................................

Now a philosophical theory, treatise, system -- or 'Grand Narrative' as the 'anti-system' philosophers or 'deconstructionists' like to call the 'system-philosophies' -- is likely to have numerous 'smaller theses' in it, all part of the workings and construction of the 'whole philosophical system' if you will. Now this would seem to explain the fact that various philosophers can put together various 'negations' of the same philosophical system. For example, Kierkegaard rebelled agaist Hegel's abstractionism (as opposed to Kierkegaard emphasis on concrete existence), Schopenhauer against Hegel's reason and rationalism (as opposed to Schopenhauer's irrationalism and pessimism), and Nietzsche against Hegel's long-winded, systemic Grand Narrative (as opposed to Nietzsche's supposed anti-systemic philosophy althogh Nietzsche did seem to be promoting his Superman, tightrope, abyss, and Dionysian philosophy which would seem to be at least partly systemic as well, if not quite as long-winded as Hegel's more Apollonian Grand Narrative.

So the deconstructionists -- primarily Kierkegaard, Schopenhauer, and Nietzsche -- picked apart Hegel's philosophy to the point that it came crashing off the wall like Humpty Dumpty. But a funny thing happened on the way to the forum. Humpty Dumpty did not die. In fact, Humpty Dumpty was put back together again by a legion of 'post-Hegelians'. Marx (turned Hegel upside down but kept the dialectic and the conflict between 'class thesis and anti-thesis' alive (the bourgeous vs. the proletariat). Nietzsche (in 'The Birth of Tragedy' before Nietzsche himself rejected his own work as being 'too Hegelian'). Freud (The Id (thesis), The Superego (anti-thesis), and the Ego (synthesis). Jung (the personna (thesis) and the shadow (anti-thesis). Perls (topdog (thesis), and underdog (anti-thesis).

Kierkegaard, Schopenhauer, Marx, Nietzsche, Freud, Jung, Foucault, Derrida, Perls...all made important evolutionary additions to Hegel's dialectic theory. But through it all, Hegel's dialectic evolutionary theory has climbed back on the wall -- as Humpty Dumpty, back together again, all in one piece, and stronger than the classic rendition. Hegel has been 'existentialized' -- and it incorporates Nietzsche's precursor to, and Derrida's later, 'Deconstruction Theory' just as easily as it can be called a 'structural Grand Narrative'. Indeed, it is the paradoxical and multi-bi-polar evolutionary element in Hegel's dialectic theory -- especially after the Hegelian snowball incorporates elements of Kierkegaard, Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, Freud, Jung, Perls, Derrida...and also appreciates the full legacy and ancient sophistication of the first Hegelian philosopher -- Anaxamander, 1350 years before Hegel -- that make's Hegel's dialectic theory, in this theorist's opinion, the greatest of all theories, the greatest of all Grand Narratives. Gap-DGBN Philosophy is one version, one post-Hegelian rendition, of Hegelian Classic Dialectic Theory, modernized, and very much alive and kicking as it rolls into the 21st century.

db, Feb. 12th, 2007.

A DGB Rendition of Nietzsche's 'Tightrope, Abyss, and Superman' Philosophy

We all need to climb onto the Nietzschean tightrope overlooking the abyss of our existence - not all the time, but on a decently regular basis - so that we can reflect on, feel on, and act on, the dialectical contrasts between our 'non-being' vs. our 'being and becoming' selves. Some people - let us call this first group of people the 'risk takers' - may need to visit their existential tightrope more often than others, while other people - let us call this latter group of people the 'security seekers' - may not want to visit their existential tightrope at all, or at least, as seldom as possible.

Having reflected on this situation for a while, I have come to the conclusion that it might be useful to differentiate between different types of 'existential tightropes'. Specifically, I have distinguished between ten different types of existential tightropes that offer ten different types of challenges to our existence.

Common to all these different Nietzschean tightropes is the Nietzschean idea of the 'Superman philosophy', the 'will to power', or better translated in most cases perhaps - 'the will to excel'.

In this regard, we can talk about 1. the 'Apollonian-Socratean-Platonic tightrope' of law, ethical idealism, and civil order; 2. the 'Dionysian tightrope' of pleasure, sensuality, sexuality, hedonism; 3. the 'Rousseauian tightrope' of love and romance; 4. the 'Marxian tightrope' of social and political activism, 'self-fulfilling' vs. 'self-alienating' work, issues pertaining to economic stability and status, and our propensity for 'acting on our goals' as opposed to just sitting around and 'thinking about them'; 5. the 'Hegelian tightrope' of negotiating conflicting differences of opinion and want; 6. the 'Spinozian-Scholastic spiritual tightrope' of wholism, unity, family, community, and altruism. 7. is the 'Heraclitean-Aristolean-Baconian-Lockean' tightrope of science, process-thinking, and empiricism; 8. is the 'Jamesian tightrope' of common sense, simplicity, and pragmatism; 9. is the 'Derridian rebellious-deconstructionist tightrope' of anti-status-quo, process and structure. In a more negative vein, unless we are talking about the area of 'sports and games', we might talk about man's obsession with 10. the 'Anaxamanderian-Foucauldian tightrope' of power, control, revenge, and war.

The essence of all these Nietzshean tightropes, metaphorically speaking, is that every time we step onto, or climb onto, one of these tightropes, we are going to feel an adrelanine rush - a mixture of anxiety and excitement - to the extent that we are actually going to tightrope walk to the other side, over the abyss opposite our 'home base-cliff' that we just left the sweet security of.

In each case, we might reflect, feel, and act on the actual essence of the tightrope walk of our life and existence. The adrenaline rush and the contrast to what we just left then is this: that we are actually walking on the tightrope, using our mental faculties, and our passion, our adrenaline rush, and our arms and legs to actually get us to the other side, and in so doing, stretching the limits of our capabilities and potentialities to their maximum -- as opposed to just 'hanging out there', hanging onto the rope for dear life, waiting for someone to come and rescue us from the rope overlooking the abyss - the danger and anxiety - of our existence...This is the difference between 'existential self-suffiency' and 'existential dependency'. We can also contrast the combined adrenaline rush of anxiety and excitement of being on one of our existential tightropes with the safety of the home-base cliff which can become our prison rather than our home if we are unwilling to leave its safety for the danger of the tightrope walk across the abyss.

This is my interpretation of Nietzsche's 'Superman philosophy', and it is the starting-point of my own personally modified post-Hegelian, post-Nietzschean, post-a-lot-of-philosphers-and-ideas...'Gap Multi-Dialectical, Humanistic-Existential Philosophy'...

The 'tightrope' formula is generally fairly simple: the more responsibilities we take on - up to a certain threshold of tolerance at least - the more we challenge our own capabilities and potentialities; in contrast, the more we seek to avoid responsibilities - at least of the kind that would legitimately challenge our abilities and potentialies - the more we are going to wrestle with the problem of 'existential insufficiency and alienation' - and extended further if it is happening more or less all the time - of a 'beingless existence' - or worded otherwise - an existence without the challenge and meaning of 'self-striving' and 'self-fulfillment'...We all have to 'go to trial' at various points in our lives -- the Franz Kafka/Joseph K. type of trial...(Franz Kafka, The Trial, 1925, "SOMEONE must have been telling lies about Joseph K., for without having done anything wrong he was arrested one fine morning..." ). The type of trial I am talking about is an 'existential trial' - a trial about the accountability and responsibility we all must take for leading and/or having led, either a meaningful, substantiated life with many 'tightrope climbings and extensions of our existence' - or the opposite - the type of life where we are always watching someone else take on the responsibilites and challenges while we watch from the sidelines, we watch from the home base cliff while someone else is climbing one of the existential tightropes. At the end of the day we are left feeling unfulfilled and unsubstantiated by our lack of courage and/or effort. In this case, we see and feel the abyss with the greatest of clarity, first with anxiety, by looking down rather than ahead to the other side of the cliff, to our goal, But even worse is when we feel the abyss in the pit of our stomach and in the core of our heart because we have led a life that has not sufficiently contacted ourselves and the limits of our capabilities, and/or not contacted anyone else in a sufficiently meaningful way. (See Samuel Beckett, Waiting for Godot, 1948.) The good news is that we can change the direction - and the substance - in our life, at any moment in time, with any change in behavior, small and/or large. But to do this, we cannot avoid the Nietzschean existential tightrope(s).

dgbn,
david gordon bain,
dialectical-gap-bridging-negotiations
democracy goes beyond narcissism

Sunday, May 13, 2007

On Bridging Some of The Gaps Between Hegel, Feuerbach, God, Religion, Marx, Capitalism and More...

The philosophical jump from Hegel to Marx was, and still is, colossal in its practical significance and impact. It is often stated that Marx stood 'Hegel's philosophy on its head' -- or from a Marxian perspective 'planted Hegelian philosophy properly on its feet after it was Hegel himself who had put his own philosophy improperly standing on its head'. Alas, everything is perspective.

Let us be clear on my perspective. I view myself as a capitalist idealist and Reformist with perhaps some socialist ideas thrown in there to the sum of about 25%. Thus, as a starting point let us say that I am about 75% capitalist idealist and reformist, 25% socialist idealist and reformist. I do not view myself as a Marxist except in parts of his early humanistic work-alienation theory, not in his later economic socialist and/or communist theory. You look at Canada today and you see that we have a network of 'social assistance' programs and 'unemployment' programs designed to help those who are perceived by government officals as being in the most legitimate and dire need. Whether you like it or not -- and I think most 'Liberal and NDP-minded people (even some Conservatives) appreciate the necessity and importance of some form of 'social saftey nets' to help avoid the possibility of people actually dying of poverty in their homes and/or on the street) -- Canada has been very much influenced by the development of socialist ideas.

You don't have to go all the way with Marx to still appreciate the fact that he was undoubtedly the most impressive critic of Capitalism in the history of Western philosophy. Any legitimate capitalist idealist and/or reformist needs to read Marx to get a strong understanding of some of the problems of capitalism, both in Marx's time, and as capitalism has evolved into what it is today. That does not mean that you have to follow Marx's thought process to either socialism and/or communism. It just means that a good capitalist idealist and reformist should and will take a hard look at Marx's criticisms of Capitalism -- and even some of Hegel's preceding ideas on 'alienation' and the 'master/slave' relationship.

The philosophical bridge between Hegel and Marx is an outstanding paper written by Ludwig Feuerbach called 'The Essence of Christianity' in 1841.

Through Feuerbach's monumental paper, Hegel's philosophy from 'The Phenomenology of Spirit' (1807) underwent 'transformational criticism' of a provocative kind -- a 'Copernican switch' if you will. And this dealt with the issue of God and religion.

Writes Robert C. Tucker, editor of 'The Marx-Engels Reader' (1978, pg. xxii, Introduction):

'For Hegel man is spirit (God) in the process of self-alienation and self-realization, i.e., man presents himself in history as self-alienated God.'

Through the process of history, and more appropriately through 'historical-cultural-philosophical evolution', man gradually overcomes his self-alienation and moves closer and closer towards a position of 'Absolute Knowledge', 'The Spirit of God' and Perfection. Thus, through the evolution of man's history, according to Hegel, man is moving closer and closer to a full self-awareness and an awareness of God, the two being intimately connected. (my addition).

Back to Tucker (1978, pg, xxii, Introduction):

'The truth, says Feuerbach, is just the reverse. Instead of seeing man as self-alienated God, we must see God as self-alienated man. That is, when man, the human species, projects an idealized image of itself into heaven as 'God' and worships this imaginary heavenly being, it becomes estranged from itself; its own ungodly earthly reality becomes alien and hateful. To overcome this alienation man must repossess his alienated being, take 'God' back into himself, recognize in man -- and specifically in other human individuals -- the proper object of care, love, and worship. Such is the basic argument of Feuerbach's 'Essence of Christianity'.'

Now one of my favorite philosopher-politicians is Thomas Jefferson. As I try to sort out my own ideas on God and religion, I just read to quotes by Jefferson that I like and will repeat here:

'Shake off all the fears of servile prejudices, under which weak minds are servilely crouched. Fix reason firmly in her seat, and call on her tribunal for every fact, every opinion. Question with boldness even the existence of a God; because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason than that of blindfolded fear.
-- Thomas Jefferson

The essence of what he is saying here that I like: 'Question with boldness even the existence of God.'

And the second quote:

Say nothing of my religion. It is known to God and myself alone. Its evidence before the world is to be sought in my life: if it has been honest and dutiful to society the religion which has regulated it cannot be a bad one.
-- Thomas Jefferson

I like this quote because of its 'functional' approach to God and religion. In other words, the value of God and religion cannot always appropriately be measured in terms of their very arguable 'epistemological realness'. Maybe God and religion should be more appropriately evaluated in terms of the significance, the meaning, and the functional value that they have on the way that we live our lives. Is anybody going to argue with the meaning, the significance, and the functional value that God and religion played in Mother Teresa's life? Certainly not me. What a courageous, wonderful, loving, giving person. Now you contrast the significance of how God and religion played such an integral part of Mother Teresa's life with the way that someone like Osama bin Laden has used and abused the name of God to play out his own power, hatred and revenge fantasies -- and you get the essence of the meaning of what Jefferson was saying when he said: 'Say nothing of my religion. It is known to God and myself alone. Its evidence before the world is to be sought in my life: if it has been honest and dutiful to society the religion which has regulated it cannot be a bad one.'

Character -- and the way that God and religion are used functionally and/or pathologically, sadistically, masochistically, and/or otherwise maliciously in a person's life -- these things make all the difference in the world when we are talking about the importance and/or the pathology of God and religion. It is all in how they are used in a person's life.

Now let us switch over to Marx. Marx was heavily influenced by Feuerbach's 'transformational criticism' and 'inversion' of Hegelian philosophy. Except Marx was more interested in the influence of economics on mankind than he was interested in the influence of God and religion. So Marx simply 'transformed' Feuerbach's 'transformation' -- from God and religion to economics, work production, the 'bourgeoisie' vs. the 'proletariat', and 'dialectical materialism'.

In my opinion -- and this is one place where I differ from Marx -- there is nothing black and white about capitalism. No all-encompassing generalizations can be made. Every private corporation and every public corporation is an individual entity in itself and needs to be judged as such. Indeed, if proper evaluations are going to be made about a corporation or institution -- especially the larger it is -- then sub-evaluations are going to be needed to be made concerning each individual department of the corporation or institution -- regardless of whether this is a private or public corporation or institution.

Everything depends on the style of leadership and the ethics and the level of 'humanistic-existentialism' (meaning the level of human compassion, fairness, worker freedom, creativity, and autonomy, etc.) that is allowed to exist within the confines of the individual company.

To be sure, every company has its bottom line, has certain functions that it has to perform well in order to keep contracts, continue to have customers, and stay in business. Some companies have more room for margin of error than other companeis do. Some companies may be functioning on a very thin line between success and failure, between profit and loss.

However within this parameter of the success or failure of a company -- indeed, oftentimes very much tied up with it -- are such factors as 'style of leadership', 'degree of ethics', 'freedom and autonomy of the worker', 'degree of creativity for the worker', 'amount remuneration (pay level), 'degree of feedback and creative negotiation between the employer (or manager or supervisor) and the worker...and so on. Again, no massive generalizations and conclusions can be made relative to how a hundred thousand totally different companies are run -- and even the different departments within each company -- and thus, for Marx to make any massive generalizations and conclusions about the 'nature of capitalism and employer/employee relations and employee/work relations' in every different work setting, in every different corporation -- is fundamentally faulty.

This may even be more so today than it was in Marx's time. In Marx's time the style of leadership may have been generally more 'Draconian' and 'anti-humanistic'. There may have been more 'sweat shops' and 'child labor' and inhumane work practices. Coal workers going to work in the dark and coming home in the dark, and perhaps dying prematurely because of the type of dust that they were breathing all day in their lungs. If you go back a few centuries earlier than Marx, Spinoza (1632-1677) died prematurely (at 45) from 'grinding lenses (glass)' for a living. His work may or may not have been 'creative' -- but if you die 20 or 30 or 40 years prematurely because of the nature of your work, then we can probably say that it was not a very good line of work. (However, people do what they believe they have to do in order to economically survive.) As a taxi driver, I used to drive a middle-age man (50-55) back and forth to the hospital who was dying of emphysema. He had worked in a printing shop much of his life and probably also was not breathing good things into his lungs. There are more laws that exist today that are designed to make the work place a safer place to work -- but these laws may not always be properly monitored and enforced in individual company situations. In some cases, there are existing health hazards that may be as dangerous today as 400 years ago without the laws. Safety laws are only as good as the people -- employers and employees -- who do or don't respect them, and short cuts are often made -- dangerous short cuts -- to save money.

It's all in the style of the leadership. You can have a Draconian capitalist boss. You can have a Draconian socialist boss. Lenin and Stalin will never go down in the books of history as 'humanitarians'.

The argument has been made that we strive idealistically for 'democracy' in our style of government. Why do we not strive for the same in our corporate-work environment. A very good question.

Well, one of the counter-arguments that is likely to be made is this: the employees haven't invested their life savings into the business; the employees don't own the business -- and if it goes 'under', then they just go out and get another job. The owner(s) of the business might be financially ruined for years to come, even perhaps for the rest of their life/lives. They aren't likely to walk away 'scott-free' -- they may be saddled with a level of debt-load that the average employee would not want to have any part of, or take any responsibility for. Thus, the final decisions should go to the person(s) who have the most shares and/or money and/or the courage and ingenuity to start up the company. Delegations of 'lesser authorities' can be passed on down the line according to the decisions of the principle owners/shareholders of the company. Yes, this is more of a 'military' style of management as opposed to a democracy but there is a reason why a military style of management is used in the military and not a democracy style of management. Sometimes -- oftentimes -- a democracy style of management is much slower and less efficient in its speed and efficiency of decision-making.

I am a dispatcher by trade -- part way between the manager and owners of the company on the one side, and the drivers who I dispatch to on the other side. I've been hired presumably because of the competence of my dispatching skills relative to overseeing the work and efficiency of the drivers. I am not paid to make regular mistakes and misjudgments -- sometimes they happen -- but if they happen too often, or management doesn't like my style of dispatching, or they think that a computer can do it better, then I am likely out of a job, or may have diminished responsibilities.

For the most part, I try to treat my drivers humanely, make decisions that are good for both the company and my drivers but sometimes what a driver thinks is best for him will conflict with what I think is best for the company. And sometimes in these cases, I have to 'draw rank' on the driver. I tell him he does the call or 'he's off the air'. No more calls for him. He works by himself or he packs up and goes home -- or he changes his mind and decides to do the call. This is not a democracy. I am being paid, firstly, to make sure that the business is properly covered. I try to the best of my ability to mix 'fairness' and 'humaneness' into my decision-making process but sometimes I have to tell a driver to 'suck it up' and do the call that he or she doesn't want to do.

Sometimes decisions are made above me regarding money and how the drivers are paid -- that I don't like, that I don't think are fair to the driver. I had a driver that came in the other day and quit on me, on the spot, because he looked at this paycheque and saw that the company had changed the way they paid the driver without notifying him. They changed from paying him by the hour to paying him by the kilometre. It probably cost him about $200-300 on his paycheque. I told him I basically agreed with him, I didn't think that it was fair for them to change pay systems without notifying him -- but there was a gray area here -- all the full-time day drivers were in the process of switching over, and had signed contracts to the new deal -- it's just he wasn't a full time day driver who had signed a new contract; he was a part-time night driver who was caught in the middle of a switch that he did not like, and as he said, he did not sign up or agree to. So out the door he went. I probably wouldn't have made the decision management made regarding the part-time night drivers who some nights might have trouble getting enough kilometers to make them want to come in and work at night. However, regarding the day drivers, one could easily detect a difference in their level of motivation. Now they were much more willing to stay out and do extra calls -- especially if they had good kilometers attached to them -- whereas before when they were being paid on an hourly rate, to the maximum of 12 hours a day, they would have been quick to ask me to cover them after their 12 hours was over. Trying to get a driver to stay out past his 12 hours when he was not getting paid for it was obviously like pulling teeth and I would cringe when directives would come from above me to keep a driver out 'against his will'. I was stuck between a rock and a hard place.

At the end of the day, each and every driver will undoubtedly evaluate the difference between what he or she 'used to get paid' and what he or she is getting paid now. And if there is a significant drop in the net paycheque, then I expect that there will be more drivers who quit on me, contract or no contract. The company may or may not expect this. If it happens, then they will undoubtedly simply hire new drivers who are not familiar with the 'old system of pay'. It obviously hurts the company every time we lose a good driver but the company will adjust, take a hit for a week or two while the new drivers are learning, and carry on. It pains me partly to say this but the bottom line is the profit line, much more so in some companies than in others -- some are looking for 'fair' profits, others are looking for 'gouging, narcissistic' profits; of much less importance in some companies more than others is the general health, happiness, and well-being of the employees that are working for them. Again, the level of 'humanness' and 'fairness' in style of management can differ greatly from one company to another. This raises the important distinction that I make between 'narcissistic capitalism' and 'ethical, humanistic-existential capitalism'.

We will leave it here for today.

db, May 13th, 2007.

Wednesday, May 9, 2007

On the Meaning and Origin of the Term/Concept of 'Narcissism'

In this essay, I will explore some of the roots and history of the concept of narcissism -- and my own theory of narcissism as it applies to GAP-DGB Philosophy.

Narcissism is both a good and bad thing -- and we cannot escape it because narcissism is 'hard-wired' into human nature. By 'narcissism', I am referring to a combination of 'selfishness', 'hedonism', 'egotism', and 'self-centredness'. We will call these the four 'cornerstones' of narcissism.

Kids don't need to 'learn' to be selfish. They just are -- until they are taught to keep their narcissism (selfishness and self-centredness)in check. They need to be taught 'manners', 'ethics', 'morals', 'sharing', 'giving', 'fairness', 'loving' and the like...because if they aren't then they never will. Both 'pampering' and 'neglect' can promote narcissism. A 'healthy' child is a child that learns a good balance between 'soft' and 'tough' love....'soft love' comes from 'compassion' and 'encouragement', 'tough love' comes form 'accountability'. There's no such thing as a 'perfect parent' any more than there is a 'perfect child'. We all try to teach 'balance' -- as well as achieve it ourselves -- but the pendulum is always swinging back and forth without really coming to a rest in the middle (at least until we are dead).

Similarily, in history you can find a 'prevalence of narcissism' in every generation in one form or another -- and/or 'overcompensation' against narcissism which can be just as bad. When there is too much 'suppression', 'denial' and/or 'repression' of narcissism -- narcissism always finds a way to 'leak out' in the form of 'acting out' and 'symptoms'. On the other side of the coin, too much open, unbridled narcissism in a society can lead to a breakdown or self-destruction of a society (the fall of the Roman Empire).

Two of the philosophers who wrote the most on the prevalence and dangers of narcissism -- even though they didn't call it that -- were Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679) who wrote that 'civil' life in a society would be 'savagery' (Lord of the Flies) without a strong government, strong police force, and strong army that is able to 'keep in check' and 'under control' all uncivil acts (of narcissism) -- Hobbes's account of human nature as self-interested (narcissistic) cooperation has proved to be an enduring theory in the field of philosophical anthropology; and Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860) -- the ultimate philosopher of pessimism who wrote essentially that life was essentially evil, futile, and full of suffering. (He also had the arrogance and gall to schedule his lectures at the same time as Hegel. Scopenhauer despised Hegel -- who presumably, he thought was 'too idealistic', 'too 'wishful thinking' and had to much of his 'head in the clouds' to see what was happening in the 'real world' (of suffering and savagery).

It is easy to try to equate 'narcissism' with Capitalism but that is not an equal equation because some of the most 'savage narcissists' have been 'socialists and/or communists' (Lenin, Stalin). Similarily, it is easy to say that the main fight of 'religion' is against 'human greed and narcissism' but that equation doesn't completely fit either because some of the 'greediest and most narcissistic acts' were committed by the Roman Catholic Church at the height of its power -- and of course other religions too that get caught up in their own 'power and greed'.

The origin of the term 'narcissism' came from Havelock Ellis...

Henry Havelock Ellis (February 2, 1859 - July 8, 1939), known as Havelock Ellis, was a British doctor, sexual psychologist and social reformer.

He described 'narcissism' as a type of 'sexual disorder' where a person is more or less 'in love with themselves' -- the name 'Narcissius' coming from ancient Greek mythology...

Found on the internet...

......................................................

Re: Echo and Narcissius
posted by WolfKing on 3/18/03 11:17 PM

Narcissius was a handsome young man that every woman fawned over. Narcissius was so handsome that he felt there was no comparison for his beauty and he often ignored his would be lovers or told them to leave him alone. Well Echo was a Nymph who fell in love with Narcissius, who had gotten into trouble with Hera a while back. On an expidition to find out which of the nymphs was Zeus' latest love, Hera found herself diverted by Echo's chatter until all the nymphs had fled. As a result, Hera was annoyed with Echo and herself and doomed Echo by decreeing that she [Echo] would not be able to say one word on her own. She would have to repeat the last few words of what another person had said.

Of course this wouldn't help Echo one bit in her pursuit of Narcissius. Now she could only repeat the words that he spoke to her, which were basically, "Go away" or "Leave me alone". Eventually Echo became saddened and embarassed by her situation that she hid herself in a mountain and to this day repeats the last words of travelers who speak into caves.

Narciuss, meanwhile, had found somebody that he could love. While peering into a pool of clear water he spotted his own reflection, and not realizing that it was only his reflection, reached down into the water to try to touch the beautiful face and he drowned. (In another version of the story Narcissius looked into a pool of clear water, and seeing his own reflection realized that the only person he could ever love was himself. And he died of a broken heart.)

I remember reading this from a book called "Greek Myths: Gods, Heroes and Monsters" by Ellen Switzer and Costas. I hope that helped you out.

.......................................................


Second Paper On Narcissism


There is no corner of human thought, feeling, and behavior that the phenomenon and concept of 'narcissism' does not touch. For those of my less experienced philosophy and psychology readers, if you are having trouble getting your brain and your lips around the word 'narcissism', then let me associate it with a word that I am sure you are much more familiar with -- selfishness.

So that is your starting point -- your basepoint of recognition and meaning, relative to the term narcissism. However, that is only the starting point. For those of you who may be reasonably familiar with Psychoanalysis, you might know that Sigmund Freud came to use the term 'narcissism' as one of the centrepieces of his philosophical and psychological investigation. And so it is with me. I will acknowledge my debt to Freud and indirectly, to Havelock Ellis,, who influenced Freud who in turn influenced me -- a chain reaction from Ellis to Freud through various other psychoanalytic theorists but basically arriving to me through Freud.

.....................................................................................


From Wikepedia, the free encyclopedia....


Narcissism describes the character trait of self love.

The word is derived from a Greek myth. Narcissus was a handsome Greek youth who rejected the desperate advances of the nymph Echo. As punishment, he was doomed to fall in love with his own reflection in a pool of water. Unable to consummate his love, Narcissus pined away and changed into the flower that bears his name, the narcissus.

Freud believed that some narcissism is an essential part of all of us from birth and was the first to use the term in the reference to psychology.[1].

Andrew Morrison claims that, in adults, a reasonable amount of healthy narcissism allows the individual's perception of his needs to be balanced in relation to others[2].

In psychology and psychiatry, excessive narcissism is recognized as a severe personality dysfunction or personality disorder, most characteristically Narcissistic Personality Disorder, also referred to as NPD.

The terms "narcissism", "narcissistic" and "narcissist" are often used as pejoratives, denoting vanity, conceit, egotism or simple selfishness. Applied to a social group, it is sometimes used to denote elitism or an indifference to the plight of others.

.....................................................................................


There are many questions to be asked about narcissism. Some have been asked by theorists before me. To what extent is narcissism 'natural' and 'normal'? From my perspective, it seems to be a healhty component of natural and normal self-assertion. Before you can be assertive about what you want, you need to know what you want, and to the extent that what you want is based on your own self-perceived needs and/or wishes, this is healthy narcissism.

Narcissism starts to become pathological when it 'blocks out' the needs and/or wishes of others. When we are like a horse with blinders on, and can only see what is directly in front of us, projected there like a movie screen from our own self-perceived needs and/or wishes while we are trying to live or work in a relationship where an other person may have perceived needs and/or wishes that are quite different than our own, it is here that the narcissistic person gets 'stuck'. The narcissistic person becomes like a 'pitbull' trying to force his or her jaws into other people in order to get his or her way. Get his or her way and the narcissistic person is happy; stymied, and he or she gets angry and/or moody, and will usually stay that way til the other side gives in. Intimidation and/or manipulation are usually the marks of the narcissistic person. So too is a marked lack of social empathy, social sensitivity, and/or social respect for the rights and/or opinions of and/or feelings of others.

It is important to note both the family and the cultural base of narcissism. Pathological narcissim can be 'nurtured' in a family either by neglect (a narcissistic parent or parents that ignore the child in which case the child copies the ignoring behavior of the parent(s)); or by spoiling or pampering the child in which case the child grows up thinking he or she is king or queen but without a proper social empathy and/or respect for the rights, opinions, and/or feelings of others.

From an economic and cultural perspective narcissism can be tied to both socialism and capitalism. The socialist narcissist is the person who feels entitled to whatever 'handouts' the government is willing to give him or her. This is different from the person who actually legitimately needs help from the government system; rather it is the type of person who will spend much time and energy doing what is necessary to 'manipulate the system' in his or her favor, perhaps because this is the way he or she has been taught to survive.

The influence of capitalism on narcissism and narcissism on capitalism is massive -- hugely disturbing when you think out the full ramifications of this two-sided (or dialectical) influence. So much so that I have come to differentiate between narcisistic capitalism and ethical humanisitic-existential capitalism; between narcissistic politics and ethical humanistic-existential politics; between narcissistic medicine and ethical humanistic-existential medicine; between narcissistic law and ethical humanistic-existential law; between narcissistic business and ethical humanistic-existential business; between narcissistic sports and entertainment and ethical humanistic-existential sports and entertainment; between narcissistic masculinism and/or feminism and ethical humanistic-existential masculinism and/or feminism...

What is the relationship between narcissism and capitalism in this regard? Simply this. It creates conflict of interest between ethical capitalism and unethical capitalism. Unethical capitalism becomes a short cut to the fulfillment of human greed -- invariably at someone else's expense which is why narcissistic capitalism and unethical capitalism are essential one and the same thing. The game often becomes 'two in, one out' -- 'let's you and me get rich at someone else's (for example, the public's) expense'. This is what you call a 'kickback' or 'feeding' scheme. Two people or sets of people are feeding each other at the expense of a third party that is left outside in the dark not knowing what is happening -- unless or until the third party finds out. Then we may have a 'scandal' that blows up and hits the fan -- for example, the media if it is big enough -- and then the two people or two sets of people who have been playing 'two in, one out' may have egg on their respective faces and may either get fired or have a lot of explaining to do or even end up in a court of law with their freedom at stake. Too often government officials get off with slaps on the wrist where a private, corporate person might go down a lot heavier. (Witness the trial of Conrad Black.) The punishment for a government official should at least be that of what would be relevant for a private, corporate person; if someone in government is responsible for 'losing' or 'misappropriating' millions of dollars of public pension fund money, for example, then this is a huge violation of public trust money and not something that should roll off our backs like water off a duck's back. But unfortunately, we have become way too 'immunized' to the expectancy and continuity of 'government narcissism' --its taking what it wants and not having to account for what it is doing -- to the point that government officials keep doing it because they feel confident they are not going to get caught, and that even if they are, the consequences will not likely fit the crime, and in the mean time they may have set themselves up to be very rich for after they retire as politicians. The government -- and this does not seem to be tied to any one party -- narcissism (greed, power, egotism...) corrupts most if not all parties, Liberal and Conservative alike, from Trudeau to Mulroney to Cretien --all have all been guilty of anything from very bad budgets to at the very least having members of their party guilty of personal violations of public funds.

When politicians continue to dig deeper and deeper into our pockets for more and more tax money, as much of the middle class continues to drop in their collective standard of living because their paycheques are not keeping up with their expenses, not keeping up with inflation, not keeping up with higher rent and mortgages, and higher food bills, and higher energy bills, and higher utility bills, and the aforementioned higher tax bills, when our senior citizens are getting hit even harder because they are now operating on small pensions that are a pittance of what they used to earn and what they paid to the government in pension money -- all this while government officials can write off huge personal expenses on gold-plated expense accounts, probably have tax-free exemptions that the rest of us could only dream about (politicians should be paying the same taxes that the rest of us do -- how else could they even begin to feel our pain?), even while they are earning 100,000 dollar salaries and packing away pensions that would leave the rest of Canada nauseous if they fully knew the details of them; at the very least, these same politicians should be held accountable for proper ethical standards and they should be held accountable when they do not spend our tax and pension money in the way that they say they are going to spend it.

I remember a high end hockey agent -- Alan Eaglson, to be specific -- who I believe got jail time and heavy fines for his fraudulant behavior relative to the hockey players whose pension funds he controlled and violated. Something tells me that his crime would pale compared to what has happened to much of Canada's billions of dollars of pension money, parts of which has been steered in other directions.

Now this is important. When I was working for the TTC, I used to get a printout periodically of how much pension money I had in my account. The total of my account was a combination of my own contributions plus those of the TTC which I believe equalled mine. But the point is that there was transparency here. Everything was above board. Everything was visible. When I left the TTC after 12 years, I walked away with about $50-60,000 in pension money that I put into RRSPs. What I put into my pension money, I took out of it, in combination with what the TTC added to it. This is basically how an ethical pension plan should be run.

But what about the way the government runs our pensions plans? Do we see the same method of operation? No. The way that the government handles our pension money would be illegal if it was being handled that way by a private corporation or a pension agent. No visibility. No transparency. All is secret. Do I know how much money I have contributed to my pension plan in the government? No. Do they tell me? No. Do I get printouts each year showing me how my pension plan is growing each year? No. Does money in equal money out, or will it ever? No, of course not. This is why we have a government pension fund that is continuing to grow at an astronomical rate -- a hugely greater rate than what is being used from it. So the question becomes, what are they doing with all the billons of extra dollars in the pension fund? Where are parts of it -- significant parts of it -- going? Who is being held accountable for telling us what is happening to all of the people of Canada's pension money that is not going back to the people of Canada? No one. This is the mark of a narcissistic, unethical government -- if not a downright illegal one (except they make their own laws for themselves). This is not the mark of a democratic, ethical government. And Harper's government -- as much as he said that he would walk in and clean up the ethical side of government -- continues to run the Canadian Pension Plan as per usual. In the dark. Do I trust Harper's ethics? No. I trust Gomery's ethics. But how much of Gomery's report on the Liberal Ad Scandal was actually implemented by the Conservative Government? Precious little, probably. Most of it pushed away into some back library. The Conservative Government had its own 'ethics' agenda, and for the most part it didn't include Gomery. Gomery was a man, an honourable judge, who for about 2 years captured the respect and the awe of the people of Canada. Here was a man who took no garbage, took no bullshit. Like a farmer, he ploughed through the bullshit, cleared out everything in his way that was hampering him from getting to the truth -- making politicians everywhere around him in his path uneasy, if not shaking in their boots -- who had a right to feel exactly this way because Gomery was exposing them, showing the Canadian people, what these politicians were doing in the dark from where they were accustomed to freely working from. They weren't used to someone checking on their business, checking on their ethics. Really checking on their ethics. Who is accountable for telling us what is happening with all our pension money?

My parents could be living without worrying if they had access to all the pension money that they put into the Canadian system. As much as they love Prince Edward Island, they probably wouldn't have been forced to move out there if they had access to the full extent of the money that they put into the Canadian Pension Fund. Or at the very least, they might actually be able to take one worry-free vacation every year. But alas, what goes in does not always equal what comes back out when dark forces are at work. A 'siphoning' process seems to be happening in between 'in' and 'out' that the Canadian people know far too little about -- just enough to know that something is happening that is probably dirty but without the full insight, and what's worse, without the full committment to demanding that a man like Gomery be put in charge of a full-scale investigation aimed at fully finding out what has been happening to our pension money for the last 20 or so years. He is the only man who I would trust to properly do the job. Anyone else -- especially one with parisan ties -- and I would expect a 'whitewash', not the truth. Let's say go back to about 1990. Off the top of my head, I think we could possibly be looking at the biggest scandel, the biggest misappropriation of Canadian money, in the history of Canada. But maybe I'm just blowing hot wind without substance. I don't think so. What is the old saying? Where there is smoke, there is usually fire.

A democratic government should be a transparent government, and it is only narcissistic govemerments that need to hide their financial activities, it is only narcissistic goverments that have trouble with transparency. Because they do not want the public to see what they are up to with our money. They like to operate behind closed doors. They like to operate in the dark. This is the modus operandi of a narcissistic, unethical goverment -- or any private corporation, or person, as well.

That is a good start for what we mean relative to the concept of narcissism -- individual, corporate, political, cultural...

db, May 9th, 2007. Link: http://hegelshotel-dgb-ethics.blogspot.com/